Completed Alone in the Dark New Nightmare.
Not sure if the second disc was less play tested, or I just started loosing patience with this game.
The circle of stones stumbled me. Carnby says you need to call Eileen to decipher the inscriptions, but when you do, nothing happens. I thought that maybe the game glitched out on me. Looked into the guide.
But for some reason you need to decide what one of the inscriptions means. Was I supposed to know it somehow?

Then the statue in the greenhouse. I thought I should push it, tried a couple of times, and figured out I must be on the wrong track. Turns out, it needs to be pushed from a perfect angle .
The last part, when you meet with Eileen and run in the caves together is nice, albeit pointless, because soon Edward gets sucked into World of Darkness, all alone again.

At first I thought it’s some Gigerian dimension. But radio with Eileen still works, so it must be just the caves beneath the island. You are given a lighting gun with plenty of ammo to find and what looks like endless enemies. Not exactly “survival horror”.
This entire episode is bizarre, as they rendered a lot of those unique backgrounds. For what? You run through those rooms as fast as possible, just not to fight endless enemies.
You fight Alan who turned into some kind of a gaunt zombie. When you damage him enough, you can grab a spear, which I don’t think was ever mentioned, and stab him to death. Because what is stronger than a rocket launcher? A spear, of course!

I have zero motivation to play the second scenario, which is a shame, really. It does seem like Eileen playthrough would be significantly different. Not only she has a radically different starting point, but also Edward never visits the fort or meets Obed, the less evil brother, for that matter. So some events, like Obed’s transformation, are never explained.